COLUMBUS CREW SC
MLS Cup Titles: (3) 2008, 2020, 2023
Conference Titles: (4) 2008, 2015, 2020, 2023
Division Titles: (3) 2004, 2008, 2009
Playoff Appearances: (19) 1996, 1997, 1998, 1999, 2001, 2002, 2004, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2014, 2015, 2017, 2018, 2020, 2023, 2024, 2025
CREW SC IN THE PLAYOFFS
YEAR
 DIVISION
 W
 L
 SOW
 SOL
 PTS
 FINISH
1996
 East
 11
 12
 4
 5
 37
 4th
1997
 East
 12
 13
 3
 4
 39
 3rd
1998
 East
 15
 12
 0
 5
 45
 2nd
1999
 East
 13
 9
 6
 4
 45
 2nd
YEAR
 DIVISION
 W
 D
 L
 PTS
 FINISH
2000
 Central
 11
 5
 16
 38
 4th
2001
 Central
 13
 6
 7
 45
 2nd
2002
 East
 11
 5
 12
 38
 1st-Tie
2003
 East
 10
 8
 12
 38
 5th
2004
 East
 12
 13
 5
 49
 1st
2005
 East
 11
 5
 16
 38
 6th
2006
 East
 8
 9
 15
 33
 6th
2007
 East
 9
 10
 11
 37
 6th
2008
 East
 17
 6
 7
 57
 1st
2009
 East
 13
 10
 7
 49
 1st
2010
 East
 14
 8
 8
 50
 2nd
2011
 East
 13
 8
 13
 47
 4th
2012
 East
 15
 7
 12
 52
 6th
2013
 East
 12
 5
 17
 41
 8th
2014
 East
 14
 10
 10
 52
 3rd
2015
 East
 15
 8
 11
 53
 2nd
2016
 East
 8
 12
 14
 36
 9th
2017
 East
 16
 6
 12
 54
 5th
2018
 East
 14
 9
 11
 51
 4th-Tie
2019
 East
 10
 8
 16
 38
 10th
2020
 East
 12
 5
 6
 41
 3rd
2021
 East
 13
 8
 13
 47
 9th
2022
 East
 10
 16
 8
 46
 8th
2023
 East
 16
 9
 9
 57
 3rd
2024
 East
 19
 9
 6
 66
 2nd
2025
 East
 14
 12
 8
 54
 7th

CREW SC IN THE PLAYOFFS
[ ] - Score After Penalty Kicks  AET - Score After Extra Time * - Away Goals
YEAR
 ROUND
 OPPONENT
 WON/LOST
 GAMES
1996
 East Semifinals
 Tampa Bay Mutiny
 Lost
 1-2
1997
 East Semifinals
 Tampa Bay Mutiny
 Won
 2-0

East Finals
 D.C. United
 Lost
 0-2
1998
 East Semifinals
 MetroStars
 Won
 2-0

East Finals
 D.C. United
 Lost
 1-2
1999
 East Semifinals
 Tampa Bay Mutiny
 Won
 2-0

East Finals
 D.C. United
 Lost
 1-2
YEAR
 ROUND
 OPPONENT
 WON/LOST
 SCORE
2001
 MLS Quarterfinals
 San Jose Earthquakes
 Lost
 0 Points to 6
2002
 East Semifinals
 San Jose Earthquakes
 Won
 6 Points to 0

East Finals
 New England Revolution
 Lost
 2 Points to 5
2004
 East Semifinals
 New England Revolution
 Lost
 0-1, 1-1
2008
 East Semifinals
 Kansas City Wizards
 Won
 1-1, 2-0

East Finals
 Chicago Fire
 Won
 2-1

MLS Cup
 New York Red Bulls
 Won
 3-1
2009
 East Semifinals
 Real Salt Lake
 Lost
 0-1, 2-3
2010
 East Semifinals
 Colorado Rapids
 Lost
 0-1, 2-1 [5-4]
2011
 East Knockout Round
 Colorado Rapids
 Lost
 0-1
2014
 East Semifinals
 New England Revolution
 Lost
 2-4, 1-3
2015
 East Semifinals
 Montreal Impact
 Won
 1-2, 3-1 AET

East Finals
 New York Red Bulls
 Won
 2-0, 0-1

MLS Cup
 Portland Timbers
 Lost
 1-2
2017
 East Knockout Round
 Atlanta United
 Won
 0-0 [3-1]

East Semifinals
 New York City FC
 Won
 4-1, 0-2

East Finals
 Toronto FC
 Lost
 0-0, 0-1
2018
 East Knockout Round D.C. United
 Won
 2-2 [3-2]

East Semifinals
 New York Red Bulls
 Lost
 1-0, 0-3
2020
 East First Round
 New York Red Bulls
 Won
 3-2

East Semifinals
 Nashville SC
 Won
 2-0 AET

East Finals
 New England Revolution
 Won
 1-0

MLS Cup
 Seattle Sounders FC
 Won
 3-0
2023
 East First Round
 Atlanta United FC
 Won
 2-1(2-0, 2-4, 4-2)

East Semifinals
 Orlando City SC
 Won
 2-0 AET

East Finals
 FC Cincinnati
 Won
 3-2 AET

MLS Cup
 Los Angeles FC
 Won
 2-1
2024
 East First Round
 New York Red Bulls
 Lost
 0-2 (0-1, 2-2[4-5])
2025
 East First Round
 FC Cincinnati
 Lost
 1-2(0-1, 4-0, 1-2)