Overall Championships -- 23
YEAR	SPORT	RUNNER-UP
1986	Field Hockey	Bloomsburg Huskies
1994	Men's Lacrosse	Hobart Statesmen
1995	Men's Lacrosse	Nazareth Golden Flyers
1999	Men's Lacrosse	Middlebury College Panthers
2003	Field Hockey	Middlebury College Panthers
	Men's Lacrosse	Middlebury College Panthers
2004	Field Hockey	Middlebury College Panthers
	Men's Lacrosse	Nazareth Golden Flyers
2005	Field Hockey	Messiah Falcons
	Men's Lacrosse	Middlebury College Panthers
2007	Men's Lacrosse	SUNY Cortland Red Dragons
2008	Men's Lacrosse	SUNY Cortland Red Dragons
2009	Field Hockey	Messiah Falcons
2010	Women's Lacrosse	Hamilton Continentals
2011	Men's Lacrosse	Tufts University Jumbos
2012	Men's Lacrosse	SUNY Cortland Red Dragons
2013	Women's Lacrosse	Trinity Bantams
2014	Women's Lacrosse	Trinity Bantams
2016	Men's Lacrosse	Tufts University Jumbos
2017	Men's Lacrosse	Rochester Institute of Technology Tigers
2021	Baseball	St. Thomas Tommies
	Women's Lacrosse	Tufts University Jumbos
2023	Men's Lacrosse	Tufts University Jumbos