| YEAR |
CHAMPION |
RUNNER-UP |
SCORE |
| 1995 |
Richmond Kickers |
Cocoa Expos |
3-1 |
| 1996 |
Central Coast Roadrunners
|
Cocoa Expos
|
2-1
|
| 1997 |
Central Coast Roadrunners |
Cocoa Expos |
2-1 |
| 1998 |
San Gabriel Valley Highlanders |
Jackson Chargers |
3-2 |
| 1999 |
Chicago Sockers |
Spokane Shadow |
3-1 |
| 2000 |
Chicago Sockers |
Mid Michigan Bucks |
1-0 |
| 2001 |
Westchester Flames |
Calgary Storm |
3-1 |
2002
|
Cape Cod Crusaders
|
Boulder Rapids Reserve
|
2-1 OT
|
2003
|
Cape Cod Crusaders
|
Chicago Fire Reserves
|
2-0
|
2004
|
Central Florida Kraze
|
Boulder Rapids Reserve
|
1-0
|
2005
|
Des Moines Menace
|
El Paso Patriots
|
0-0 (6-5PK)
|
2006
|
Michigan Bucks
|
Laredo Heat
|
2-1
|
2007
|
Laredo Heat
|
Michigan Bucks
|
0-0 (4-3PK)
|
2008
|
Thunder Bay Chill
|
Laredo Heat
|
1-1 (4-1PK)
|
2009
|
Ventura County Fusion
|
Chicago Fire
|
2-1
|
2010
|
Portland Timbers U23
|
Thunder Bay Chill
|
4-1
|
2011
|
Kitsap Pumas
|
Laredo Heat
|
1-0
|
2012
|
Forest City London
|
Carolina Dynamo
|
2-1
|
2013
|
Austin Aztex
|
Thunder Bay Chill
|
3-1
|
2014
|
Michigan Bucks
|
Kitsap Pumas
|
1-0
|
2015
|
K-W United FC
|
New York Red Bulls U-23
|
4-3
|
2016
|
Michigan Bucks
|
Calgary Foothills FC
|
3-2
|
2017
|
Charlotte Eagles
|
Thunder Bay Chill
|
2-1
|
2018
|
Calgary Foothills FC
|
Reading United AC
|
4-2 AET
|