| YEAR |
CHAMPION |
RUNNER-UP |
SCORE |
| 1996 |
Charleston Battery |
Charlotte Eagles |
3-2 SO |
| 1997 |
Albuquerque Geckos |
Charlotte Eagles |
4-1 |
| 1998 |
Chicago Stingers |
New Hampshire Phantoms |
3-2 OT |
| 1999 |
Western Massachusetts Pioneers |
South Jersey Barons |
2-1 |
| 2000 |
Charlotte Eagles |
New Jersey Stallions |
5-0 |
| 2001 |
Utah Blitzz |
Greenville Lions |
1-0 |
2002
|
Long Island Rough Riders
|
Wilmington Hammerheads
|
2-1
|
2003
|
Wilmington Hammerheads
|
Westchester Flames
|
2-1 2OT
|
2004
|
Utah Blitzz
|
Charlotte Eagles
|
2-2 (5-4PK)
|
2005
|
Charlotte Eagles
|
Western Massachusetts Pioneers
|
2-2 (5-4PK)
|
2006
|
Richmond Kickers
|
Charlotte Eagles
|
2-1
|
2007
|
Harrisburg City Islanders
|
Richmond Kickers
|
1-1 (8-7PK)
|
2008
|
Cleveland City Stars
|
Charlotte Eagles
|
2-1
|
2009
|
Richmond Kickers
|
Charlotte Eagles
|
3-1
|
2010
|
Charleston Battery
|
Richmond Kickers
|
2-1
|